Etsy evidence
Etsy cases where a single unboxing photo decides the outcome.
Etsy disputes are usually small-value and decided fast. The winning move is a clear photo set and a record that proves the item left in the stated condition.
What they ask for
- Photos of the finished item before packing
- Packing footage for the specific order
- Tracking and dispatch date matching the case
- Any customisation proof (personalisation notes) if relevant
Policy source
Link to the official policy page is added before launch. Until then, verify inside the case form.
How to answer it
- 01Open the case and read what the buyer actually claims.
- 02Export the Etsy variant: image set first, clip second.
- 03Answer the specific claim — damaged, wrong item, or not received — with the matching image.
- 04Keep the response short and factual.

Common rejections
Why a good clip still gets refused.
Mistake 01
Sending the same generic image set for every case
Mistake 02
Missing the personalisation proof on custom orders
Mistake 03
Over-long replies that bury the point
Etsy questions
What sellers ask us.
Have another question? Write to [email protected] — we reply within one business day.
Do I need video for Etsy?
Usually no. A clear image set tied to the order is enough; the clip is a backup.
What proves personalisation was correct?
The order note, the design file and a photo of the finished piece next to the packing slip.
Can I reuse a pack across cases?
No. Each pack is bound to one order and one timestamp.
Deadlines and formats are indicative and were read from public documentation on 17 November 2026. Confirm inside the case form before relying on them.
Next step
Answer a Etsy claim in under a minute.
Same record, different export. Set up one bench and test it against a real order.